Červenka Consulting

Load Transfer between RC Columns of Different Sections under Cyclic Loading

Cyclic tests and ATENA analyses of RC column connections with a change of section: bent bars lowered the strength, straight and diagonal bars restored it.

Source: J.-H. Koo, J.-Y. Park, S.-H. Kim, H.-G. Park. Load transfer between upper and lower concrete columns with variable sections under cyclic lateral loading. Journal of Building Engineering 119 (2026), 115323. doi:10.1016/j.jobe.2026.115323 (subscription access).
Seoul National University, Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute, Pukyong National University

Residential buildings often change the column section between storeys: rectangular wall-columns above, smaller square columns below to free space for parking, lobbies or shops. The change of section moves the column centroid and creates an eccentricity exactly where the seismic forces pass from one column to the next through the beam, slab and joint.

Capacity design requires the plastic hinge to form in the upper column, while the lower column, beam and joint are designed with an overstrength factor so that they do not fail first. This had not been tested for connections where the section changes and where bent bars are used to route the reinforcement from the wider upper column into the narrower lower one.

Tests and analysis

Four large-scale specimens (about 1:2 to 1:3 scale) were tested under cyclic lateral loading according to ACI 374.2R. Connections with moment-resisting beams were compared with connections supported only by slabs. The width reduction between the upper and lower column (40 % and 25 %) and the use of the overstrength factor for the lower column were varied.

An elastic truss model was used to predict the load-transfer mechanism and the peak strength. Nonlinear finite element analyses in ATENA modelled cracking, damage and reinforcement yielding in the connection region. After the ATENA model had reproduced the tests, it was used for a parametric study of axial load ratio, three alternative reinforcement details in the joint and the storey drift of the whole building.

Results

  • All four specimens behaved in a ductile manner. Where bent bars transferred the reinforcement from the upper to the lower column, yielding penetrated into the joint and the joint crushed prematurely; the peak strength was 73 to 95 % of the design value.
  • With a 40 % width reduction and without the overstrength factor for the lower column, the failure moved from the intended hinge in the upper column to a brittle flexural-compression failure of the lower column.
  • The elastic truss model predicted the strength well in one loading direction (test to prediction 1.03 to 1.13) but overestimated it by up to 43 % in the other. After the bent-bar detail was included, the ratios were 0.90 to 0.96.
  • The ATENA model reproduced the load-displacement response, the peak strength and the damage pattern of the tests.
  • In the ATENA parametric study, straight vertical bars with additional diagonal bars in the joint reached the full design flexural strength even at an axial load ratio of 40 %, where the bent-bar detail and a detail with vertical bars only did not.
  • With increasing first-storey drift, the lower column behaves more like a cantilever, especially for the larger width reduction, and its load-carrying capacity drops below the value from an isolated connection test.

The authors recommend capacity design with an overstrength factor of at least 1.25 for the lower column, beam and joint, a detailed truss or nonlinear finite element analysis of the connection, and checking the connection for the storey drift of the whole building. The macro models used for global building design do not capture the behaviour inside such a connection.

This page summarises independent, peer-reviewed research by Seoul National University, the Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute and Pukyong National University. Červenka Consulting was not involved in the study; it is presented as an example of ATENA used in research and practice.

Zeptejte se AI na program ATENA